Dave Ramsey Baby Steps and Crown Money Map Round Up

Do you like the Dave Ramsey Baby Steps or the Crown Money Map?  Dave Ramsey created the Baby Steps and Crown Financial Ministries created the Money Map for prioritizing and setting financial goals.

If you’re just joining, this is article #7, the round up article.  It is the last in a series about The Baby Steps and Money Map.  With each post I’ve stepped through the phases of both approaches, discussed my observations, hopefully, stimulated your thinking and raised some questions for thought.

In this final post I plan to bring both approaches together and discuss the ultimate benefit in following either one of them for your plan.  But first, I’ll list the first six phases of the Baby Steps and Money Map.

baby steps

Baby Steps:

  1. $1,000 In An Emergency Fund
  2. Pay Off All Debt With The Debt Snowball
  3. 3 To 6 Months Expenses In Savings
  4. Invest 15% Of Income Into Roth IRAs And Pre-Tax Retirement Plans
  5. College Funding
  6. Pay Off Your Home Early

Money Map

Money Map:

  1. Begin using a spending plan & save $1000 for emergencies.
  2. Pay off all credit cards and increase savings to one month’s living expenses.
  3. Pay off all consumer debt & increase savings to 3 months living expenses.
  4. Begin savings for major purchases (home, auto, etc.).  Begin saving for retirement.  Begin saving for children’s education.  If you want to start your won business begin saving for it.
  5. Buy affordable home.  Begin prepaying home mortgage.  Begin investing wisely.
  6. Home mortgage paid off.  Children’s education is funded.  Confirm estate plan is in order.

Baby Step 7 – Money Map Destination 7

What does the Baby Step say?

  • Build Wealth and Give.

What does the Money Map say?

  • My retirement is funded.
  • I am free to to be more generous with my time and money.

Observations and Questions

  • The Money Map scripture in this destination is Matthew 25:21.  “Well done good and faithful servant.”
  • Obviously, both plans come together in the final phase with the key theme of giving and building.
  • Are you in pursuit of a final destination of financial freedom and giving more, or is your pursuit more focused on short – term gratification?

Round Up

The ultimate benefit in following either of these two approaches is financial freedom.  You see, there is no longer a need to get rich or pursue quick money making schemes or chase after fruitless desires.  Most of those things, if pursued, without living from heaven backwards don’t produce anything but a pile of problems.  Don’t misunderstand, I don’t have anything wrong with having toys, fun vacations and more, but pursuing these things without a plan for the future (for financial freedom) is exhausting.  They never lead to financial freedom.

These approaches bring focus and precision to financial goals.  You can’t get to a destination if you’re constantly taking a wrong turn or getting distracted along the way.  No, you must have a map, or steps to guide your direction.  You have to know the impacts of stalling out.  For instance, if I continue to acquire debt, or don’t make progress towards paying off my debts, I’ll probably never have enough for retirement and to ultimatly build wealth, give more, etc.

My wife and I made a decision a long time ago to pursue a financially free life.  A life in which we could give more of time and money to help others.  I know that we can only get there by following the course presented by these two approaches.  Wouldn’t you agree it would someday be great to hear, “well done good and faithful servant?”

Is either approach right or wrong?  Which one is better?  In my opinion, neither approach is right or wrong.  The one that is better is the one that fits your situation.  That sounds like a bit of a cop out given the content I’ve posted recently around this dance, but it’s true.  To be honest, I’ve found a combination of the two phases that I find works best for our family (upcoming post).

So, what do you find works best for you?  Are you into Baby Step’n or Money Map’n?

Free Email Newsletter
The Weekly Article Newsletter Delivered Straight to Your Inbox!
Get this free handy eBook that provides 25 ways to save money on your cell phone bill.

About Jason

Jason started blogging in 2009 when he created One Money Design. Since then it has grown into a group of writers with unique personalities and a common goal of helping people on the journey to true financial freedom. Jason is an IT project manager by day, but you’ll find him blogging about personal finance and exploring web entrepreneurship late at night and the early hours of the morning. He’s also actively involved in a financial coaching ministry in his community where he shares principles of biblical stewardship and helps people learn to manage their money wisely. Jason enjoys spending time with his wonderful wife and two awesome children and lives in north Dallas. Twitter | Facebook | +Jason Price

, , ,

  • Erin Beaver

    Hi Jason,

    I was glad to find these posts (albeit 2 years after they were written). You may or may not be aware of last night’s kickoff of The Great Recovery (www.thegreatrecovery.com), but I’m hoping that this will open up the conversation of bringing a financial ministry to my growing church. I like that you arrived at the conclusion that both programs are good and eventually end up in the same place.

    I don’t know if you’ve been through FPU (I think I saw in a comment that you and your wife were planning to take the course just to see what it’s about), but in case you haven’t or others stumble upon this blog, I just want to draw a quick line of clarification.

    The Total Money Makeover book is not a part of FPU. Dave uses his book “Financial Peace Revisited.” FPU is not the same as Dave’s Baby Steps. It includes them, yes, but the class is 13 weeks long, and there’s only 7 Baby Steps, so what else is covered? Here are the lesson titles [with my clarification in brackets]:

    Lesson 1: Super Saving [Baby Step overview, "What's an emergency?" and begin "Quickie Budget"]
    Lesson 2: Relating with Money [getting on same page as spouse, nerd vs. free spirit, teach your children, monthly budget meetings]
    Lesson 3: Cash Flow Planning [creating detailed zero-based budget, using envelope system, cash-only living]
    Lesson 4: Dumping Debt [detailed info on Debt Snowball, views on credit cards]
    Lesson 5: Credit Sharks in Suits [prioritizing the "four walls"--clothing, food, shelter, and transportation; dealing with creditors; checking credit report]
    Lesson 6: Buyer Beware [communicate with spouse about large purchases, marketing techniques, gaining power over purchase]
    Lesson 7: Clause and Effect [the insurance lesson]
    Lesson 8: That’s Not Good Enough! [negotiation skills to get the best value, the power of cash]
    Lesson 9: Of Mice and Mutual Funds [the investing lesson, includes some retirement]
    Lesson 10: From Fruition to Tuition [retirement and college planning]
    Lesson 11: Working in Your Strengths [career planning, finding success in work]
    Lesson 12: Real Estate and Mortgages [what to know about buying and selling a house]
    Lesson 13: The Great Misunderstanding [financial stewardship, tithing, giving]

    I just wanted to put that out there for comparison. A quick note that Dave uses biblical principles and different verses in his instruction, though I feel like his program, while it is meant to appeal to Christians, is also set up so that he does not alienate non-believers. My husband and I went through FPU in 2008. We’ve since moved to a new town, new church. And now we’re looking to start The Great Recovery. And while I really like Dave’s approach, I’m also open to learning about Crown’s.

    I still don’t quite understand how Crown is delivered? Are there classes? Or is it individual?

    Thank you for taking the time to write out these comparisons. I am continuing my research.

    Erin